German court rules against Peruvian farmer in landmark climate lawsuit

(28 May 2025)
RESTRICTION SUMMARY:

ASSOCIATED PRESS
Hamm, Germany – 28 May 2025
1. Wide shot of people gathering outside the courthouse for the Peru climate case
2. Climate activists setting up a "Justicia Climática" display
3. Mid shot of a protester holding a sign advocating for the protection of Huaraz people in the climate case Saul vs. RWE
4. Close up of a sign reading "Saúl vs. RWE"
5. Wide of court room and attendees at climate case before start of session / announcement of verdict
6. Camera pan right from RWE lawyers to judges and plaintiff’s attorney Roda Verheyen
7. Mid of RWE lawyers
8. Judges, among them presiding judge Rolf Meyer
9. Wide of supporters applauding outside court room as plaintiff’s attorney Verheyen arrives after announcement of verdict
10. Verheyen speaking via video call to farmer and mountain guide Saúl Luciano Lliuya after announcement of verdict
11. Mid of video call on a laptop screen showing Lliuya
12. Wide of journalists and activists
13. SOUNDBITE (German) Roda Verheyen, plaintiff’s attorney:
"Saúl, we have just heard a very long explanation from (presiding) judge (Rolf) Meyer about why the precedent is as we discussed. Today we have reached the major precedent, you have reached it."
14. Mid of a video call on a laptop screen showing Lliuya
15. Camera pan right of activist and journalists
16. SOUNDBITE (German) Roda Verheyen, plaintiff’s attorney:
"The important thing is that the legal obligation of companies like RWE has been established here today. The legal obligation to deal with the consequences of their actions and to take responsibility for them. This is something that has never been established anywhere in the world in this form before, and that is why I can only be speechlessly happy today. And from tomorrow on, we will continue to work on Saul’s problem on the ground in Huaraz, because of course, the rejection of the appeal today also means that this problem is not resolved."
17. Mid of a video call on a laptop screen showing Lliuya, UPSOUND of applause
18. Set-up shot of head of media relations at RWE, Matthias Beigel
19. SOUNDBITE (German) Matthias Beigel, head of media relations at RWE:
"Yes, this is a good day for us. The court has decided that the lawsuit against RWE was unfounded and thus the attempt to create a legal precedent here has clearly failed in this second instance as well. We also consider it a completely wrong approach to shift climate policy demands through NGOs into German courtrooms. If this sets a precedent, soon every German industrial company would be confronted with climate lawsuits from all over the world. That cannot be the solution. This would massively endanger Germany as an industrial location."
20. Camera operator
21. SOUNDBITE (German) Matthias Beigel, head of media relation at RWE:
"The lawsuit has been dismissed, thus the legal proceedings are initially concluded here. And from our perspective, no legal precedent has been established."
22. Set-up shot of spokesman of the higher regional court in Hamm, Daniel Große-Kreul
23. SOUNDBITE (German) Daniel Große-Kreul, spokesman of higher regional court in Hamm:
"The court has dismissed the plaintiff’s appeal against the district court’s verdict. It has also not allowed the revision, and in combination with the determination of the disputed value, this judgment is thereby legally justified. The court has thus determined, after intensive expert assessment, that there is no danger to the plaintiff’s property."
24. Person wearing a shirt advocating accountability
27. Exterior of court
STORYLINE:

Find out more about AP Archive: http://www.aparchive.com/HowWeWork
Twitter: https://twitter.com/AP_Archive
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/APArchives ​​
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/APNews/

You can license this story through AP Archive: http://www.aparchive.com/metadata/youtube/be88645813cc430fb1a105be427b4fae

Author: AP Archive
Go to Source

News post in June 2, 2025, 3:04 pm.

Visit Our Sponsor’s:
News Post In – News

Renegade_Rcih
Greetings I'm Renegade Rich, I own lots of websites and domain names. one of my favorite news type of sites are news sites. So I own lots of news sites and news domain names. My lates is https://news.post.in 😁